McCulloch v. Maryland
McCulloch v. Maryland Landmark Decision of Supreme Court of United States :
McCulloch v. Maryland is one of the landmark case in the history of the American jurisprudence where Supreme Court of United States decided on the powers of Congress on the State governments . United States is a Federal State which means there is a division of powers between Federal Government and the State Government . In 1816 Congress chartered the Second Bank of the United States which was opposed by many states governments . Some states opposed the function of the Bank and prohibited them in their jurisdiction . More than five states imposed taxes on the Second Bank of United States . Many states in the country faced economic difficulties due to the credit and lending schemes of the bank . James W McCulloch a federal cashier in the Baltimore branch of the bank refused to pay the taxes imposed by the state of Maryland on the bank . U.S. Bank in Maryland issued bank notes without paying the taxes and the case against the McCulloch was filed in the state courts of Maryland . The State Courts in Maryland decided the case against the McCulloch and in the favor of Maryland state . McCulloch reached Supreme Court in an appeal against the judgements of state courts of Maryland . Whether the Congress has the power to charter or incorporate a bank and federal government has power over the state governments to make such laws was left on the Supreme Court to decide . The case was between the Federal government and the State Government and to what extent can federal government exercise its sovereign powers . The other issue in the case was , Can a State Government impose tax on the US Bank .
This case was decided by the Chief Justice John Marshall in 1819 . Justice Marshall on the issue whether Congress can incorporate a bank held that Congress has the power to charter a bank under the constitution and on the issue whether state governments can impose or ban the taxes on the bank held that State cannot make such laws and has no power to impose tax on the banks . Clause 18 of Section 8 Article 1 of the Constitution says "The Congress shall have Power to make all Laws which shall be necessary and proper for carrying into Execution the foregoing Powers, and all other Powers vested by this Constitution in the Government of the United States, or in any Department or Officer thereof" . This means by the Necessary and Proper clause of the constitution Federal Government has all the power to make laws , which are of necessary and proper in nature in order to carry its powers granted by the Constitution . The laws made by the Congress must be legitimate and it should be in the consonance with the Constitution . Referring this Article Chief Justice Marshall decided on the dispute between the Federal Government and the State Government . He held it is not explicitly mentioned in the constitution about the powers of Federal government to create bank but under the under the necessary and proper clause Federal government can make laws to carry out its powers enumerated in the constitution . So the incorporation of bank by the Congress is constitutional in nature . The Necessary and Proper clause was incorporated in the constitution because the federal government has power to make laws only on the subjects expressly mentioned in the constitution . On the issue of State powers to levy taxes on the bank Justice Marshall decided that State Government can make laws on its subjects but imposing tax on the bank does not come under its subjects . Imposing taxes on the agency of federal government means imposing a tax on Federal Government . It is an indirect tax on the citizens of Unites States . So the tax imposed by the State of Maryland on the bank of Unites States is unconstitutional in nature .
In many parts of the countries the decision by the Supreme Court was criticized . Supreme Court interpreted the Constitution and enlarged the powers of Federal Government over the State Governments and said the power to make such law is an implied power of the Congress . The decision was believed to be against the strict and expressed implications of the constitution . This judgement later led to the foundation of New Deal in 1930 and Welfare state in 1960 in the Constitution of United States . The Court decided the case in the favor of McCulloch and the Second Bank of the United States was exempted to pay taxes to the State of Maryland .
Post a Comment